patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

TELL US: Does 'Rudolph The Red-Nosed Reindeer' Condone Bullying?

Does the lovable children's holiday classic send the wrong message? Tell us your thoughts.

 

In October, Patch asked readers how they felt about one parent's view that "It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown" condoned bullying.

Specifically, blogger DadCamp wrote that the show sends the wrong message to children because of its "continuous teasing and bullying"

It's not the first time a parent has spoken out against a classic children's program with such a claim.

Last December, news spread that author and special ed professor George Giuliani said that "Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer" was also a program laden with the theme of bullying, considering how much Rudolph was an outsider due to his glowing red nose. Giuliani, as such, wrote a book titled "No More Bullies at the North Pole," which re-tells the story of Rudolph.

What do you think? Does "Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer" send the wrong message and condone bullying? Or is the claim taking an extreme aim at a children's classic? Let us know your thoughts in the comments section below.

Related Topics: Bullying, Christmas, Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer, and Santa Claus

Patch_comments_icon

Matt Perkins

2:02 pm on Wednesday, December 5, 2012

Interested to see the feedback on this one (we had a ton of great feedback on the article regarding "It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown"). Both programs are classics focus on overcoming adversity and helping others as opposed to bullying. Thoughts?

Reply

Emcee of Seekonk

2:21 pm on Wednesday, December 5, 2012

These were my thoughts in October on Charlie Brown. The same thinking process would apply to Rudolph.

"At the time this Charlie Brown created, a hero and a bully were constant themes in literature or comics. Superman, Spiderman, etc. all represented good. The bad guy/gal or villain represented evil. Without a bully or bad actor, there can be no Superman to settle the score. Kids love this kind of stuff... or did back in the day."

When good (Rudolph gets to successfully lead the pack through the dangerous fog) triumphs evil, there is a lesson learned. In this case, the teasers look like fools. Life is full of these situations.

Reply

Marcia Huyette

2:41 pm on Wednesday, December 5, 2012

Agreed, Emcee of Seekonk and Matt Perkins!

Reply

brutally honest

2:51 pm on Wednesday, December 5, 2012

It's stories like this that concerns me! It’s called fiction and it doesn't promote anything other than Christmas people! That’s right I said Christmas and if you don’t like it, too damn bad! This whole “bully” thing is becoming a joke! Does the story of Rudolph encourage bullying? Come on people lets get serious here! The more attention we draw to it, the more kids are going to do it. And let’s be honest children who stand up for themselves are disciplined as well, that doesn’t help either. We use “bullying” as a label for anything a kid doesn’t like, and it’s really getting out of control. Instead of teaching a kid to handle it in an appropriate way, parents and schools shield their kids in glass houses and as a result kids don’t know how to handle criticism when they get older.

Reply

Amy

3:36 pm on Wednesday, December 5, 2012

No, it's a delightful childrens classic that's been around for decades.
Merry Christmas everyone!

Reply

Avon Barksdale

3:50 pm on Wednesday, December 5, 2012

Rudolph is a capitalist allegory, Ayn Rand may have written it. Goods and services - and the people who make and provide them - only have value in a capitalist society when demand exists. Nothing about Rudolph's inherent goodness and moral virtue is values by his peers or elders, it is only when he becomes indispensibly productive that he is accepted. The day that the elves create a sleigh headlamp system that can mimic his nose's illumination is the same day he goes back to being a freak, detested and scorned, and left in the dustbin of Christmas history.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Amy

4:14 pm on Wednesday, December 5, 2012

Stop trying to cheer us up!

Comment_arrow

Cynthia Rosenfeld

9:05 pm on Sunday, December 9, 2012

Ha! That is so true. And so funny to apply it to a children's Christmas classic. Well done.

Fiscal Conservative

3:58 pm on Wednesday, December 5, 2012

Avon: Great thoughts. Fully understand your ideas and thoughts. Thank God the Mayan calendar calls for the end on Dec 21, maybe then we can be removed from all this foolishness. By the way, are you planning to go up or down on the 21st?

Reply

R. Hood

7:55 pm on Wednesday, December 5, 2012

Wed 12/5: Brown tap water. Another load of laundry ruined. Yeah Foxboro!

Reply

april

9:38 pm on Wednesday, December 5, 2012

i totally agree with Brutally Honest- people need to stop coddling their kids & teach them right from wrong & also MORALS & RESPECT. nobody can enjoy anything anymore & it is getting stupid. May as well stop believing in Santa because it's all technically a LIE right? You need to draw the line somewhere people. Stop being so serious, miserable & politically correct. I don't blame kids AT ALL for rebelling. Their crazy parents need to get a life.

Reply

Bruins37

10:24 am on Thursday, December 6, 2012

Rudolph is a classic, just like Charlie Brown. People are way too sensitive today/

Reply

Janet Sroczynski

10:45 am on Thursday, December 6, 2012

These are wonderful classic children's stories and movies.

"A Christmas Carol" by Charles Dickens and illustrated by Dean Morrissey; hardcover book available at both BN.com and Amazon.com: $29.98. Scrooge.

Reply

Abe Froman

11:27 am on Thursday, December 6, 2012

Yes. without a doubt, Rudolf promotes bullying and it should be banned...forever.
While I'm thinking of it, here are some other completely fictional characters that have been dragging society down and should be banned.
1.)Woody Woodpecker….Environmental Terrorist (destroys trees)….Ban all cartoons or birds…either one…forever.
2.)Lone Ranger…Politically incorrect Indian Sympathizer…Ban all things cowboy..forever.
3.)Boba Fett…Intergalactic Assasin & Terrorist…..Ban all things Star Wars…forever.
4.)Toothfairy, Easter Bunny and Santa Clause….Known Felons (all repeat offenders…. wanted for Breaking and Entering)….ban everything fun for everyone…forever.

Reply

Avon Barksdale

11:51 am on Thursday, December 6, 2012

I do love that one random person talks crazy about Rudolph and bullying and then all the chicken littles start screaming about the decline of western civilization due to the twin evils of political correctness and the self-esteem movement.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Gretchen Robinson

2:20 pm on Thursday, December 6, 2012

way to go, Avon. What about all the folks who are still bitter, aggrieved, resentful, angry about the election? Now those 'chicken littles' are railing against the financial cliff and the end of civilization as we know it. Saw a bumper sticker today against the Affordable Healthcare Act.
It said "Lord, protect us from Obamacare." Doom and gloom. Guess the driver feels hopeless about a future where the 46 million uninsured get healthcare.
Hey folks, it's the season of Hope. It's Advent. Merry Christmas! Or the holiday of your choice. Happy Holidays.

Abe Froman

12:24 pm on Thursday, December 6, 2012

Chicken Little...Dangerous gossip monger...ban all chicken...forever.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Stoughton12

1:17 pm on Thursday, December 6, 2012

Says the Chicago Sausage King

paul

1:10 pm on Thursday, December 6, 2012

The show Gilligan's Island damaged me as a child, the Skipper was always picking on his little buddy.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Avon Barksdale

1:20 pm on Thursday, December 6, 2012

Thankfully the atrocities he committed with Lovey Howell were left on the cutting room floor.

Comment_arrow

Gretchen Robinson

2:21 pm on Thursday, December 6, 2012

"The Importance of Being Earnest"

Fiscal Conservative

2:33 pm on Thursday, December 6, 2012

Thank God, I have many more days behind me than ahead of me. This crap is depressing. I worked with some one who analyzed everything, couldn't enjoy anythig for the sake of enjoyment. His life had to of sucked!!!
I try to enjoy things, although it is difficult in this PC world. What hair I have left I'm starting to pull out because the people lack "common sense", forget what it is too be a child, always looking for the negatives...even in simple things. I think that becoming a Hermit may be the sanest move one could make. Remove oneself from all the hate. Yes, Both Liberals & Conservatives are EQUALLY guilty of this.

Reply

Gretchen Robinson

2:56 pm on Thursday, December 6, 2012

FC: check this out when you're hermit-ting.
Reuters.com - Satellite captures "black marble" view of Earth at night
http://www.reuters.com/article/email/idUSBRE8B507120121206

Reply

Amy

3:09 pm on Thursday, December 6, 2012

Oh Gretchen! I see Santas Sleigh!

Reply

Janet Sroczynski

10:49 am on Friday, December 7, 2012

Gov. Lincoln Chafee - it is a Christmas Tree. Merry Christmas!

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/11/30/bill-oreilly-chafee-fox-news-angry-network_n_2217303.html

Article and video entitled: "Bill O'Reilly Clashes with Gov. Lincoln Chafee: 'Fox News....Is An Angry Network' (video).

Reply
Comment_arrow

Emcee of Seekonk

11:17 am on Friday, December 7, 2012

Sad little Rhode Island... it'll have a blue, blue Christmas/holiday again this year.

Comment_arrow

Gretchen Robinson

12:07 am on Monday, December 10, 2012

oh, dear, I have to tell you that former Gov. Calceri called it a "holiday tree" two years in a row and no one made a fuss. Course he's Republican and Catholic so that fact was never brought up by the press or pundits.
Bill O'Reilly overblown umbrage will have heads shaking and and tongues wagging. Such a cheap shot. Do you all have to feel superior that you bash RI. Grow up with your piddly little griping. The HOLIDAY is bigger than that. It's pagan, Jewish (be inclusive of Jews, Jesus was a Jew!!); Black (Kwanza), India (Diwali --Festival of Lights). Are we so petty that we arrogate Christmas all to ourselves. It's the dark time of the year. Don't make it darker with your aggrieved rantings.

Amy

11:10 pm on Friday, December 7, 2012

Alvin just wants a hula hoop.

Reply

paul

8:42 am on Monday, December 10, 2012

Lincoln Chafee has become a modern day Burgermeister by censoring the word Christmas. His actions are a current trend to try and make everyone happy in this politically correct era that we are living in. Our politicians are giving this country away piece by piece, and they don't even know it.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Gretchen Robinson

5:56 pm on Monday, December 10, 2012

oh, give it up. You are ruining your own Christmas with all this crankiness. Remember that in the early years in Massachusetts the Puritans forbade Christmas and called it gaudy. That was a work day. And they were a near theocracy, as Roger Williams and Anne Hutchinson found out. Puritan church leaders had them brought up on civil charges.
Mostly I don't know understand why you see yourselves as victims. I just don't understand that. Do you really think the nation is under attack by raging atheists? Most people I've ever met have a live and let live attitude.

Amy

8:46 am on Monday, December 10, 2012

No one talks about Religion and God more than Athiests. Just makes us stronger.
Merry Christmas and Happy Hanukkah.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Emcee of Seekonk

10:12 am on Monday, December 10, 2012

"No one talks about Religion and God more than Athiests."

Lol. Amen.

And if one athiest is offended by the words 'Christ' or 'Christian', then we must all give up our traditions and tap dance to please the athiest. Something is mighty wrong here.

Merry Christmas.

Gretchen Robinson

5:58 pm on Monday, December 10, 2012

I know atheists who have a holiday/Christmas tree. The tree if pagan folks. Know the history of your own religion.

Reply

Indiana

10:19 pm on Monday, December 10, 2012

Good to see the 2 commies are back...Merry CHRISTmas

Reply

Gretchen Robinson

10:29 pm on Monday, December 10, 2012

Indiana, the Christmas spirit is one of peace. How about the Christian tradition of not bearing false witness, of being "ambassadors for Christ"?

Reply

Leave a comment